Truancy is intentional, unjustified, unauthorized, or illegal absence from compulsory education. Its absence is caused by students of their own free will and does not apply to excused absences. In Germany local child services or social services officers may request the police to escort the child to school, and in extreme cases may petition a court to partially or completely remove child custody from the parents.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
@99TYVNH2yrs2Y
I dont think it should be criminalized however with excessive truancy there should be an attempt made by the school to find the cause and fix the issue at hand
@9LZP5VQ7mos7MO
I don't think that the government should have much of a stance on whether it should be legal or not. It should be by the school district.
@9LZHSM27mos7MO
Depends on students background and what they are dealing with, education aside, in their personal life
@9LJSLM6Social Democratic8mos8MO
No, there should be help and assistance provided to truant students who are struggling with issues such as health problems or living situations.
No and Yes. Students should be encouraged to spend more time learning with a better school systems and those students with burn out or depressions, should get more free days to cope with it, so they don't have to stay away from school illegal in the first place.
@96LR9RKFree Voters2yrs2Y
It's quiet extreme, but also fair
No, but it would be wonderful to give children somewhat of legal possibility to homeschool a few days a half year within reason.
case-on-case scenario to make exceptions
This is a case by case basis for the school
@8VJSP243yrs3Y
Yes, it’s not a crime but it should be fined
I do not undert question
More should be invested in education so that children will want to come to school.
@8VD3M723yrs3Y
In certain cases absence from school should be allowed. E.g. the child's mental health or safety is at risk,
school should be made a place that fits to every child so that children want to go to school. Also in families where child neglect is the issue, they should be given adequate help, which isn't taking the child away from the family
@8V543YD3yrs3Y
It should be seen as child neglect, leading to an investigation of the parents.
@8TKC2SFFree Democratic3yrs3Y
Yes, unless it's clearly caused by the parents.
It should try to provide support to those who incur truancy.
Yes, school attendance should not be mandatory.
Yes, and they should offer help to the affected.
Everyone has to do His own whats right for him
@9B593N62yrs2Y
No, unless the student has an exceptional reason.
@99LK3982yrs2Y
I believe this is a case-by-case subject, and it should have regulations depending on the scenarios.
The government should respond based on the circumstances at home and other details rather than punish every student
Yes, but only if we instead then try to help the kids as usually school truancy is only the reaction to problems, like mental health issues, etc.
@99GCTGS2yrs2Y
Yes, but only with written letters from guardians or healtbcare professionals
@99DTNDSFree Democratic2yrs2Y
No, unless it is due to serious economic or family situations
It shouldn't be decriminalized for parents that hold their kids back from going to school, but the parents who have kids that skip school. They shouldn't go to jail.
@99CBV5B2yrs2Y
No unless they don't go to school at all without a valid reason
Yes, truancy problems should be handled some other way.
@998R2MV2yrs2Y
No, but lower the punishment for it
To a certain yes, but some forms of discipline should be implemented
Yes, but still require an education and daily contact to other children in some way
@9936SBR2yrs2Y
Yes, and work to learn what the needs of the child are that are not being met in the schools currently
@988SRTJ2yrs2Y
Yes, but input other punishments and incentives to prevent truancy
@97ZXQWL2yrs2Y
Various means of education should be developed to meet the learning needs of children. And the root causes of truancy must be addressed.
Decriminalize and also provide more social workers to support parents and children. Most kids are not simply "skipping school". For many, learning disabilities, discrimination in the classroom, psychological issues play a large role in skipping school.
Students with good marks should be allowed to skip school whenever they want, but truancy should remain illegal for students with poor marks.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Yes, as long as there is a sufficient reason for doing so.
Deleted3yrs3Y
No, this will cause other students to become truant due to legally not being required to be in school, which can lead to job deficiency decreasing due to lack of needed skills. Students should be mandated to receive proper educations, but establish federal guidelines for the investigation of absences and increase access to education in low income communities and more needs to be done to see why children are not going to school.
@558YLXV2yrs2Y
Yes. Truancy should be treated more from a social services perspective than from a legal perspective; criminalizing truancy only leads to increased legal problems and increased incarceration for low-income individuals.
@3ZX6S543yrs3Y
Yes, implement social workers help families identify the root problem.
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@4M78YV63yrs3Y
Yes but be very vigilante about the consequences of the action
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@5643HNN4yrs4Y
Yes, but we still need to be invested in our childrens' success by not throwing the book at them
@4V4VGHM4yrs4Y
Yes, but only after the eighth grade.
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@4XD28G74yrs4Y
Yes! School attendance should never be mandatory to the extant that criminal/civil penalties apply. People overestimate the control parents have over their children. Of course education is important and should be highly encouraged, but there is no reason for punishment as the only person it hurts is the child's future.
@8HJ8G9M4yrs4Y
I am uneducated on this issue.
@88LK76J4yrs4Y
Yes our school system is broken beyond repair
@8HDWQKS4yrs4Y
We should reform the school system through school choice, and allow parents to make educational decisions for their children.
@8P6PWZP4yrs4Y
Yes, especially when students need a mental health break.
@8R8K8WM3yrs3Y
Yes, and provide programs for students that are not committed to school.
@8P5LJL84yrs4Y
Yes as long as the student is passing
@8JP4VGF4yrs4Y
No, Students are not capable of making good decisions until they have fully matured, meaning they should stay in school and learn.
@524STTZ4yrs4Y
No, but there should be some leniencies provided for some legroom for students.
@925J4Q83yrs3Y
depends on why the student isn't going to school. If they arent going to school because they have to provide for their families, give them some way for them to go to school while they can still provide. If they aren't going because they just don't want to, make them go to school
No and parents should be held accountable for those children under 6th grade. The child should be held accountable 7th grade and above.
@8WPC6NZ3yrs3Y
do wellness checks on students who miss a lot and it is unexcused
@92JXK3J2yrs2Y
Except for truancy in which the student has done illegal activities or truancy in which the parent allows and/or ignores it, Yes, it should be decriminalized.
@8ZSXDG33yrs3Y
Depending on reasoning and if they still have access t school work to pass.
@8GYMZ3B4yrs4Y
We should reform the education system and how schools work. We need to completely redo our education system.
@8TWB9LD3yrs3Y
Some kids have jobs that require them to miss school, or have issues in their family
@9242PWT3yrs3Y
It depends on the severity.
@8PRYTBY4yrs4Y
yes, but they should be more lenient with the days they missed, and work with the student to see what if everything is ok at home.
@8R7SQ2V4yrs4Y
Decriminalize, yes. Legalize, no.
@8H4DF7B4yrs4Y
If the parent is keeping the child from school without homeschooling them then yes. But if the child is just skipping school then detention works. Also, have a team intervention approach to help the student and family deal with stresses and other factors inhibiting the attendance.
@2PR69DM4yrs4Y
Yes, but incentivize enrollment by assisting families who enroll
@5VMSTDG3yrs3Y
Regardless, it should be up to the states.
@7GLVLCC4yrs4Y
Yes, but these houses need DHS/CPS Wellness Checks and encouragement to attend and intervention when necessary
@78S5M874yrs4Y
This should be determined on a case by case basis.
@78S5M874yrs4Y
It is none of the government's business
@78S5M874yrs4Y
Yes, It is none of the government's business
@7GH4CCN3yrs3Y
No, but we should make proper education for lower income or underprivileged people more accessible.
@85QWNPG4yrs4Y
Yes, and instead contact the DHS if they have not attended school for more than 40% of the year, and after attempts to contact/agree have fallen through.
@899WSD34yrs4Y
This issue should be handled by the state governments.
@7PTCG383yrs3Y
Yes, parents should have civil but not criminal responsibility for willful school absences of their child beyond one week. Fines and other penalties should be determined by local school districts
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
Yes, but hold parents civilly responsible for willful absences of their son or daughter from school beyond one week, with fines and other penalties to be determined by local school districts.
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
Yes, but parents should be held responsible for willful absences of their son or daughter from school beyond one week, with civil fines and other penalties to be determined by local school districts.
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
Yes, but parents should be held responsible for willful absences of their son or daughter from school beyond one week, with civil fines and other penalties to be determined by local school districts
@7PTCG383yrs3Y
Yes, parents should only have civil responsibility for voluntary school absences of their child that last beyond one week. Fines and other penalties should be determined by local school districts
@8558FRW2yrs2Y
No, but focus on addressing the underlying issue for said truancy.
@8CV568G4yrs4Y
beginning at a certain age, children should be held accountable, not parents. it should also be taken situation by situation instead of generalized punishment.
@8CYG8KL4yrs4Y
Depending on the reason why the student is not attending school, if justified it should be regulated, the student should be receiving support if the reason is justifiable. If the reason is unjustified, then they should be given a weeks notice before they have to go back to school.
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
Yes, but parents should be held civilly responsible for willful absences of their son or daughter from school beyond one week. Fines and other penalties should be determined by local school districts
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
Yes, but parents should be held civilly responsible for willful absences of their son or daughter from school beyond one week. Fines and other penalties should be determined by local school districts.
@7PTCG383yrs3Y
Yes, hold parents civilly -not criminally -responsible for willful absences of their son or daughter from school beyond one week. Fines and other penalties should be determined by local school districts
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
Yes, hold parents civilly, not criminally, responsible for willful absences of their son or daughter from school beyond one week. Fines and other penalties should be determined by local school districts
@7PTCG383yrs3Y
Yes, hold parents civilly but not criminally responsible for willful absences of their son or daughter from school beyond one week. Fines and other penalties should be determined by local school districts
@8DDYNS84yrs4Y
yeah, unless the kid like never shows up and is failing classes
@8DNZHRP4yrs4Y
It depends if you are sick or just skipping school
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
Yes, but hold parents responsible for willful absences of their son or daughter from school beyond one week, with civil fines and other penalties to be determined by local school districts.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.